Star Trek Fans Upset At Potential Picard Plot Hole, But They’re Wrong
The majority of Star Trek fans I have spoken to have been suitably impressed so far by the first three episodes of Picard. Honestly, right now for me, Picard is shaping up to be one of the best Trek shows ever made. There is one little aspect that has been gnawing at some fans. It’s one of the most important plotlines of the show and some fans have been unhappy with this aspect. So, what’s new? Fans are always unhappy with any changes to franchises, and Star Trek is no different.
Picard sets up a mystery involving the Romulan Empire. In the show, the Romulans are said to have a deep loathing of all synthetic life. This was something never brought up in the previous shows. For the most part, the canon is not affected since there were no real situations where synthetic life came up with regards to Romulans. However, there is one episode some fans have turned to, to prove this is a major retcon of the canon. Fans have pointed to a classic episode of TNG called “The Defector.” In “The Defector,” a Romulan, Admiral Alidar Jarok, tells a captured Data, “I know a host of Romulan cyberneticists who would love to be this close to you.”
However, in an Instagram Q&A Picard showrunner Michael Chabon explained this away. Clearly, (though some fans won’t admit it) the writers looked into all this some time ago. The writers then made the decision to take the story in this way, knowing this epsiode would be brought up. Chabon said of the scene.
Check it out below.
I guess what Chabon is saying is that the scene could be read a number of different ways. The writers simply chose to angle that meaning towards their own much later interpretation. The fact is, that this does not break the canon and is not in fact evidence that the Picard writers do not know what they are doing. Something that a certain portion of the fan base have accused the writers of.
Does that stop some fans complaining? Hell no! On the same Instagram post, there are fans still complaining. One fan even says that although they do not see themselves as a Star Trek expert, they clearly know more about the show than the writers of Picard. I suppose I have been on the other end of this debate with Star Wars. I still maintain that the likes of J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson just didn’t get what Star Wars is, or understand some of the context of the original trilogy they copied so hard.
The difference is that the Star Wars sequel trilogy by its very nature is designed to make us look at the OT differently. Picard is very far from this. For a start, the fan service moments in Picard seem less frequent and also more earned than we saw with Star Wars. It’s also not trying to finish a story that already had an ending. This is a brand new story that will likely be the end of the story for one character alone and that’s Picard himself.
Whether there was any hint of Romulan attitudes towards synthetic life in the old shows or not, it doesn’t matter. The point is, that the show is well written, well-acted, intriguing and mysterious. Most importantly, I agree with Chabon’s way of interpreting that classic episode. I did not at the time when I watched ‘The Defector’, but it does work. No way do I see this as strong enough to be considered a retcon. I actually think the writers have done a really good job or making sure this new concept does NOT alter the canon in any meaningful ways.
The truth is that a lot of fans seemingly wanted Picard just carry on with his role as Captain of the Enterprise. Possibly bringing back his old crew for The Next Generation reboot. The problem is that this was never on the cards. Patrick Stewart had zero interest in rebooting that show, and without Stewart, you have no Picard. Right now, based on only three episodes, I think Picard is shaping up to be one of the best Trek TV shows ever made. For that reason, I can only find praise for the entire production team.
Any Trekkies out there, where do you stand on Picard? Feel free to come at me if you have issues with the way Picard has been written. You can leave your thoughts below in the usual place.
Don’t forget to share this post on your Facebook and Twitter using the buttons at the top! Or you can react to the post down below.
Have you checked out LRM Online’s official podcast feed yet The LRM Online Podcast Network, which includes our flagship podcast Los Fanboys, our premiere podcast Breaking Geek Radio: The Podcast, and our morning show LRMornings? Check it out by listening below. It’s also available on all your favorite podcast apps!
SOURCE: Michael Chabon (via Instagram)
More on this: 877 stories
- Mount: Neither Lorca Nor Parker
- Star Trek: Picard Showrunner Reveals What Happened to the Ex-Borg
- Star Trek: Picard Showrunner Explains Why Riker Wasn't on the Titan in the Finale
- Showrunner Answers Big Questions About Star Trek: Picard Season 2
- 10 Things We're Looking Forward To In Season 2
- Star Trek: Picard: 5 Fan Theories That Came True In Season 1 (& 5 That Still Could)
- Star Trek: The Next Generation Cast Reunite For Quarantine Birthday Party
- O Captain! My Captain! Anson Mount of 'Star Trek: Discovery' dishes on possible return of Capt. Pike
- 'Star Trek' Cast Group Chats to Celebrate Marina Sirtis' Birthday
- Star Trek: Picard Showrunner Explains How and Why the Show Changes The Borg
- Star Trek: Picard Showrunner Explains The Show's Approach to Sexuality
- Star Trek: Brent Spiner Shares High Praise for Picard's Finale
- Star Trek TOS: 10 Real-Life Historic References In The Show
- Star Trek: Picard Showrunner Hints at Series Going in New Directions in Season 2
- Star Trek: Picard's Synthetic Villains Were Disappointing
- Picard: The Show's LGBT Romance Brings Star Trek Into the 21st Century
- Star Trek Discovery Season 3 Teaser Trailer Shows Burnham In The Future
- Stay At Home Edition: Bits & Pieces
- 'Battlestar Galactica' is a Bingeable Feast Eager to Bust Your Gut
- The Challenge for 'Star Trek: Picard' Season 2
- Star Trek: Enterprise's Jonathan Archer reminds us that mistakes happen
- Star Trek: Picard's Finale Finally Brought [SPOILERS] Back To Starfleet
- Star Trek: Picard EP Says Season 2 Will Go In A Different Direction
- Star Trek: 10 Historic Moments In Star Trek That We've Already Lived Through
- Star Trek Picard: What is Will Riker's New Ship?