Star Trek: A Classic Story Is Presented the Way it Was Intended
A classic Star Trek episode is presented the way its original creator intended in IDW Publishing’s The City on the Edge of Forever: The Original Teleplay. Based on the late science fiction novelist Harlan Ellison’s original screenplay of the same name, this five-issue miniseries was adapted by Scott and David Tipton, who have worked on other IDW Star Trek books, with painted art by J.K. Woodward of Fallen Angel fame.
The original filmed version of “City on the Edge of Forever” is classic Star Trek; it regularly appears in fan and critic lists of best StarTrek episodes from across the entire franchise. What fans may not know however is that what was ultimately aired and what original writer Harlan Ellison intended were two different things. Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry was not happy with some elements of Ellison’s script (more on those in a minute) and rewrote whole parts, but not enough to get co-writer credit; the aired version is still fully attributed to Ellison. Ellison’s original screenplay was later published in book format and circulated among fans; IDW’s adaptation is the first mass release of this version, and the differences are on full display.Click the button below to start this article in quick view. Start now
The basic plot remains the same: a drugged-out crew member jumps through a time portal and alters Earth’s history beyond recognition. Kirk and Spock must then travel to the past to restore events. In both stories, a woman named Edith Keeler, and her death, is integral to the plot; both versions feature Kirk falling in love with Keeler. The similarities end there. In Ellison’s version it is not Doctor McCoy who travels back to the past and alters history, it is a random crew member caught dealing in narcotics, which Roddenberry apparently had issues with. The Guardian of Forever, the time portal, is also different. And at the end, the strung-out officer is killed, ripped apart by the currents of time.
Despite this different ending, the stories arrive at the same moral conclusion: Kirk and company return to their present, and Kirk lives out his life haunted by the loss of the one woman he actually loved. Compounding the loss is she had to die in order for history to be restored - a fact which the logical Spock (who deals with old-fashioned Earth racism as he and Kirk try to subsist in the past) reminded him of throughout their adventure.
IDW’s adaption of Ellison’s original vision for the story is a fascinating opportunity for Star Trek fans to revisit this episode from a new angle, with Ellison focusing more on the darkness and urgency found in the clash between human weakness and higher responsibilities. Some elements are out of character for Trek, such as a narcotics-addled Starfleet officer, but at its core it is pure Star Trek: a heavy ethical dilemma coupled with compelling characterization.About The Author
More on this: 762 stories
- Star Trek News: Franchise to get Legacy Award at event and more
- The 'Korra Effect' Keeps Fans Coming Back
- Star Trek: 10 Unpopular Opinions About Enterprise (According To Reddit)
- Star Trek: Discovery Reveals an Old Federation Enemy is Now an Ally
- Star Trek Discovery Theory: Mirror Michael Killed Emperor Georgiou's Son
- Star Trek: Voyager Just Turned Seven of Nine Into a Revolutionary
- Star Trek Voyager's "Endgame" Repeated A Season 5 Episode (But Worse)
- Star Trek: Voyager's Seven of Nine Tests Her Humanity in New Comic
- Star Trek To Receive Legacy Award at Critics Choice Super Awards
- Star Trek: Discovery: Who Will Be Saru's New Number One?
- Star Trek: Discovery Continues A Running Deep Space 9 Joke
- Star Trek Discovery: Who Will Be the New Number One?
- Star Trek: Discovery: SPOILER Gets Demoted
- Star Trek Producer Herb Solow Dies at 89
- Herbert F. Solow, Desilu Exec Behind 'Star Trek' and 'Mission: Impossible,' Dies at 89
- Discovery Turns Star Trek's Delta Badges Into 32nd Century iPhones
- Star Trek: 'Burnham Goes Rogue' Has Become Discovery's 'They Shut Down the X-Files'
- 5 of the best Star Trek tweets this week, from fun to history
- Star Trek: Discovery's Best Replacements For Michael As First Officer
- Hero Collector Starships Coming In February 2021
- Stewart And Roddenberry To Receive Awards
- Star Wars: The Mandalorian Nominated for Best Science Fiction/Fantasy Series at Critics Choice Super Awards
- Throwback Thursday: Star Trek TNG's Elementary, Dear Data (S2, Ep 4)
- Star Trek: Every 32nd Century Upgrade To The Discovery
- Nominees For 1st Annual Critics Choice Super Awards Include 'Palm Springs', 'Birds Of Prey', And 'Lovecraft Country'